Econowave Speakers

From MAKE Magazine

From MAKE Magazine

This project first appeared on the pages of MAKE magazine.

Turn good vintage speakers into great modern ones.

  • Add Note x

Last year on the Audiokarma (http://www.audiokarma.org) discussion boards, members Zilch and Jackgiff shared a project that rocked the online audiophile community. They designed a treble waveguide and crossover system that greatly improves the sound from older speakers with “fried egg” style tweeters.

Waveguides are horns that disperse high-frequency sounds evenly over a wide area, rather than letting them fall off at the sides. This gives the speakers “constant directivity,” which means they sound more natural to listeners who aren’t in the center sweet spot, between and in front of the speakers.

Zilch and Jackgiff also designed a replacement crossover circuit that balances the sound across the new combination’s optimal 1,600Hz crossover point, routing low frequencies to the speaker’s great original woofers and high frequencies to the new compression drivers. Zilch sells PCBs for building this crossover.

I tried the conversion myself on some 1970s-era Advent Large speakers. It cost a couple hundred dollars, but the results were outstanding: the modified old Advents performed like thrillingly clear, state-of-the-art speakers that audiophiles pay thousands for. Since then, I’ve built and sold a second pair, and many other Audiokarma members have built multiple pairs of these speakers.

Sections
Files
Tools
Relevant parts
Relevant parts (continued)
  • Band-Aids
  • Horn driver (2), titanium, Selenium D220Ti-8 1", 8-ohm, 12"-18 TPI screw mount aka compression drivers; $41
  • ZilchLab EconoWave crossover PCBs (2) from ZilchLab, i_am_zilch@att.net, bare board for $20 or fully assembled for additional cost. Or you can wire the crossover circuits on plain breadboard.
  • L-pad volume controls (2), 50W mono, 1" shafts, 8-ohm $10
  • Resistor (2), Dayton Audio precision Audio Grade, 10W: 16Ω (2), 30ΩBuy it
  • Capacitor (2), Dayton Audio metallized polypropylene, 250V: 0.47µF (2), 4.7µF (2), 12µF
  • Inductor coils (2 of each), 0.60mH, 20-gauge, air core and 1.5mH, 18-gauge, I-core
  • Painter’s tape
  • Speaker wire (9'), 2-conductor , 18 gauge or larger,
  • Plywood (2), pieces, 5"x5"x10mm thick
  • Plastic tubing, Stiff, 1/4" or larger, 2" length for screw spacers. You can use the barrel of a stick ball-point pen.
  • Binding post (2 pair), Dayton Audio BPA-38G HD aka speaker terminals
  • Speaker gasketing tape, 1/8"x3/8"x50'
  • Sheet metal screws (20), #63 5/8" with matching washers
  • Wood screws (8), #6 , 3/4" (4), 5/8"
  • Refoaming kit optional; if the foam is decayed around your original woofers. I recommend the kits from Rick Cobb, rcobb@tampabay.rr.com.
first image
thumb image 1
thumb image 2
thumb image 3

Add Note Edit Step 1 — Take them apart.  ¶ 

  • Pull off the speaker grilles and then wrench off the grille attachment blocks that are stapled and glued to the baffle. Unscrew and pull out the woofer and tweeter, cutting their wires. Pry off the plastic trim.

  • Wearing a dust mask and gloves, pull out the fiberglass batting and set it aside in a closed bag.

  • Pull out the staples and chisel off the glue inside to remove the original crossover circuit. Sand off any glue residue. Repair and refinish the cabinet as desired.

  • Tip: Never use steel wool on a loudspeaker; it sheds steel particles that clog the driver’s magnet gap.

  • Note: On old speakers, the foam around the woofers may have cracked and disintegrated. This compromises the air seal essential to the bass performance and makes the woofer rattle and sound bad. Fortunately, it’s 100% repairable. You can use a kit to replace the foam surround yourself (see Parts list), or take them to a repair shop; I like Audio Atlanta (http://www.audioatlanta.com).

first image

Add Note Edit Step 2 — Cut the waveguide holes.  ¶ 

  • In each speaker baffle, cut a 10½"x5" clearance hole for the new waveguide, aligning the top edge with the existing tweeter hole. I taped off the area, drew cut lines, and used a jigsaw with a 3" blade.

  • Tape over the cabinet rim and hold the jigsaw above it to avoid scratching it. Drop the waveguide in.

  • Mark and drill the ten 1/16" mounting holes.

first image

Add Note Edit Step 3 — Build the crossover circuit.  ¶ 

  • Assemble a crossover circuit for each speaker, referring to the schematic. It’s easiest to build them on the printed circuit boards from ZilchLab, which come with instructions, but the circuit is simple enough to wire together neatly on plain breadboard.

  • Solder three 8" single wires running offboard for the L-pad tweeter volume control. The L-pad uses 2 potentiometers, a series and a shunt, to let you adjust the tweeter’s volume without changing its overall impedance.

  • Also solder two 24" 2-conductor speaker wires for the woofer and tweeter, and mark the positive (+) lead on both.

  • Crimp the slide-on connectors provided with the compression driver onto the tweeter leads.

first image
thumb image 1
thumb image 2
thumb image 3

Add Note Edit Step 4 — Mount the electronics.  ¶ 

  • Note: The crossover circuit, L-pad, and speaker terminals are mounted to a 5"x5" square of plywood inside the cabinet.

  • Drill a 3/8" hole through the plywood for the L-pad knob shaft, and 9/32" holes spaced 3/4" apart for the speaker posts, close enough to the L-pad so they’ll all fit through the cabinet’s original terminal hole in back. Also drill a 1/8" hole at each corner of the plywood panel, for mounting it.

  • Solder the L-pad wires to the L-pad terminals, following the schematic and labels 1, 2, and 3 on the board. Rim the cabinet’s terminal hole with foam gasketing tape, and then mount the plywood panel to the speaker with screws.

  • Position the crossover board on the inside of the panel, and screw on the knob and posts on the other side, using washers if necessary. Secure the crossover board over the speaker terminal shafts using the supplied nuts.

  • Finally, screw down the free edge of the crossover board, opposite the terminal shafts, with #6x3/4" wood screws and plastic-tubing spacers cut to size.

first image
thumb image 1
thumb image 2
thumb image 3

Add Note Edit Step 5 — Final assembly.  ¶ 

  • Pull the speaker leads through their baffle holes, leaving plenty of slack inside, and tape them to the edge of the cabinet. Carefully replace the fiberglass batting, loading it evenly. Replace the cheesecloth behind the woofer hole, and rim the woofer and waveguide holes with more foam gasketing tape.

  • Screw the compression driver to the waveguide, connect the tweeter leads, and mount the waveguide to the baffle with ten #6x5/8" sheet metal screws and #6 washers.

  • The waveguide fits the Utility model without trimming, but the other speaker models require some more work. With the Original Large Advent, sand 1/16" (or less) from both sides of the waveguide to make it fit. The New Large Advent has a bit less space, so you can trim  1/4" off each edge of the waveguide, or get tricky with a router and undercut the walnut rim to make room to slide the waveguide edge underneath. I’ve seen both done, and I’d just cut away the plastic waveguide edge myself, rather than attempting fancy router work.

  • To reinstall the plastic trim, shave it down where necessary to clear the waveguide rim on each side. Nail in the top, bottom, and one side piece using  1/4" brads, and screw in the other side so it can be removed for service.

  • Solder the woofer wires to their terminals, observing polarity. Screw the woofer down and replace the grille. That’s it!

first image

Add Note Edit Step 6 — Options  ¶ 

  • Here are some additional restoration options, mostly cosmetic, that won’t affect the speakers’ sound:

    • For a homogenous appearance, paint the cabinet back, woofer frame, baffle, and screws all black. You’ll need 1/2 pint of interior latex trim paint.

    • To mount the woofers more securely, drill out their screw holes to 7/32" and press in eight 8-32 T-nuts.

    • Make new grilles using the Large Corner Grill Frame Kit and an extra set of corners (Parts Express #260-344 and #260-345). Choose thin, stretchy fabric, like polyester jersey fabric (1yd). Attach the grille with velcro tape, and the fabric with foam tape.

This project first appeared in MAKE Volume 20, page 150.

For more information, check out the Audio category page.

Did you successfully follow this guide?

This guide has been completed 1 time.

Comments Add Note Comments are onturn off

Guide Add Note

The author here. A note regarding the relative positions on the baffle of the waveguide tweeter and the woofer. We chose a position near the top of the cabinet for the waveguide hole because it incorporated the existing tweeter hole. This is not necessarily the ideal position for technical reasons. There are performance advantages to having the waveguide and woofer as close together as possible. With an Advent cabinet this means figuring a spot for the waveguide hole that positions it's rim right up against the rim of the woofer. After you cut this hole you can use some of the cut out material to patch and fill the old tweeter hole. Just cut a piece of material that will fit fairly closely, tape it in from the back and epoxy it in place. Then after it dries trim the lower edge and sand flat.

Closer positioning of the drivers results in a somewhat taller forward 'lobe' in which the woofer and tweeter outputs in the crossover region (1600 hz) are coincident and do not cancel. This matters only at listening angles that are substantially below of above the tweeter center line.

Ross Hershberger, · Reply

the Audio Atlanta link (Audio Atlanta (http://www.audioatlanta.com)) is no longer valid.

cpolarbear, · Reply

Thanks for letting me know. I don't know why that website is no longer responsive. If Audio Atlanta remains unavailable as a supplier, I recommend Parts Express as an alternate. The sell driver refoaming kits. They also have speaker rebuild services. parts

Express is also the source of most of the crossover components used in this build.

Ross Hershberger, · Reply